Are Bed Bug Dogs Up to Snuff? - Pest Management Professional

Are Bed Bug Dogs Up to Snuff?
PMPs must consider many factors when evaluating the use of canine scent detection as a bed bug inspection tool.


Pest Management Professional

Bed bugs are one of the hottest topics in pest management today, and they pose significant challenges for hoteliers, property managers, furniture rental companies and homeowners, just to name a few. One thing that virtually all experts agree on, however, is the importance of detecting bed bugs early on, before populations become entrenched at accounts.

The problem is that to date, there are no effective or reliable methods for the early detection of bed bugs. Or are there?



Dogs have been used very effectively for the detection of a wide variety of things including drugs, bombs, fugitives, mold and termites. If you have been watching the news, you know that canine scent detection for bed bugs is also available.

On the surface, demonstrations can be very convincing, but be careful: Everything isn't always what it appears to be.

HISTORY REPEATS ITSELF

Termite-sniffing dogs trained in the early 1980s had a false-positive rate of more than 28 percent. (False positives occur when the dogs incorrectly indicate termites are present when there are none.)


Best In Show
We now know this high false-positive rate was because of the method of training and the purity of the training material. In light of this, we need to be careful and learn from our previous experiences in this new bed bug-detecting canines category.

It is very important that bed bug-detecting dogs be highly reliable. Their quality and effectiveness depend on several factors, including:

  • How effectively the dogs are trained;
  • What the dogs are trained to do; and
  • The ability of handlers to maintain quality bed bug scent detections after the dogs leave their original trainers.

In addition, there are uncontrollable factors: Dogs have bad days, just like people do. If the handlers or the dogs are having bad days, the dogs may not perform at their highest levels. An uncomfortable or stressful environment also can affect the dogs' performance.

BUYER BEWARE

Clearly, there is a great deal that goes into producing a highly reliable product that can be counted upon to deliver the highest quality of scent detection. Therefore, when purchasing a detection dog, you should expect full documentation to support the type of training that has taken place and data to support the abilities as well as limitations of the dogs being purchased.

You should have access to all training records, supported by a microchip number, a veterinarian-certified health certificate less than 30 days old, and a field deployment demonstration in which the purchaser places "blind hides" for the trainer to find.

With a quality training program behind the dog and a strong set of data to support the training program — and an effective handler — you should be able to confidently communicate to your clients what they should expect in the event the dog is brought in to perform bed bug inspections.

The industry doesn't need bed bug-detection dogs to find obvious infestations that can be easily identified through visual inspections. Instead, the goal of canine bed bug scent detection is for the dogs to efficiently find what humans are likely to miss. Otherwise, there's little need for canines to complement human-led bed bug inspections.

Cooper is technical director for Cooper Pest Solutions in Lawrenceville, N.J. You can reach him at 800-949-2667, or e-mail
.

What do YOU think?
Your email address will NOT be published.
appears with your comment
read our privacy policy
Note: does not support HTML
All comments submitted are subject to review, and may be delayed before posting. We reserve the right not to post comments.
What our readers think:
 Posted 2010-01-25 08:19:14.0
Hey Richard, Just ran across this old article of yours and agree as well as disagree. The biggest problem with the dogs is that non-dog people buy them to work as a carpenter would buy a saw. The handler is usualy the problem. If you are not a trained handler and just bought a store shelf dog, your failure rate will be at least 50% higher than mine. I bought my pups, I raised & trained my dogs. I work my dogs and they are 97% accurate. I am Not in the pest control business like you are. Pest control is your specialty. My specialty is training, and working detection dogs. Many of your peers think they can do what I do but they can't and don't. My bed bug dog has over 1,000 hours of training, he's only 2 yrs old. My explosives dog has over 4,000 hrs and the drug dogs are upwards of 2,000 hours each. How much trainnig time do you think most of these "store bought" dogs have ? These K-9 training centres are in the business of SELLING dogs, not finding things. So they get a one year old Beagle, train for 2-4 hours, (maybe) a day for 3-4 months. Best case scenario 480 hours of training. Once the dog is sold, to a non professional, he/she may get 3-4 days of training with the dog and that's it. The dog leaves, the new handler rarely works the dog unless there is a job at hand. I work my dogs "every day", job or no job. The daily training keeps the dog's senses sharp and current. My dogs are always ready and 97% accurate. The 3% is in case I'm having an off day. Regards, Andrew
Read More Comments
Source: Pest Management Professional,
Click here